Choosing the right cat litter isn’t always as simple as grabbing a bag off the shelf. What works beautifully for one cat may send another running in the opposite direction! Let’s explore what really matters when selecting a litter your cat will happily use.
by Rita Reimers, Certified Cat Behaviorist

Which Cat Litter Has the Right Stuff?
(and How to Choose the Right One)
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed with so many cat litter brands and types available. From clay and natural litters to silica crystals, how do you know which one your cat will actually like?
I’ve tried these litters PURRsonally, so I’m sharing my real-world experience with clumping, odor control, dust, and comfort for those sensitive kitty paws. Be sure to check out my Cat Litter Comparison Chart below!
Be sure to check out the Cat Litter Comparison Chart👇 at the end of this article, too!
What Makes a Cat Litter GREAT?
Why is choosing the right cat litter for your felines so difficult? What exactly makes a good cat litter? It sounds so obvious and simple that one wouldn’t think it could be so hard to choose. The reason I think it gets so confusing is that the brands are all marketing to what WE THINK our cats want.
More often than not, cat litter companies appeal more to cat owners than to what actually makes a cat want to use a litter box. Does it cover litter odors with perfume? Is the container of litter light enough to carry and pour? And can the company conveniently send a monthly shipment right to my door? All those qualities appeal to us humans, but not so much to our cats.
So, what do Cats Prefer?

When we consider how cats behave in nature, we can begin to understand what they expect from their cat litter. What cats really need is:
- Litter that is gentle on tender kitty paws.
- Litter that doesn’t smell like a perfume bottle broke inside of it.
- A substance they can easily scratch and dig in to cover up what they’ve left behind.
The 3 Basic Types of Litter Substrate
Consider paw feel when choosing the right cat litter

Let’s talk about the three basic types of cat litter substrates on the market and the pros and cons of each. Just about every type of cat litter falls into one of these main categories:
- NATURAL SUBSTANCE LITTERS: These litters are made from materials such as corn, wheat, nut shells, compressed pine, recycled newspaper, or tofu.
- Pros: Often made from renewable, biodegradable materials and generally more environmentally friendly than conventional clay litter.
- Cons: Some cats try to eat them, and odor control can vary depending on the material and brand.
- CLAY LITTERS: Clay is the most common type of litter on the market and often performs especially well in multi-cat households. Some varieties clump, while others don’t. We prefer the clumping brands.
- Pros: Most cats readily accept clay litter, and it’s generally affordable.
- Cons: Not biodegradable, and some varieties can be dusty.
- SILICA CRYSTAL LITTERS: Crystal litters are easy to maintain because you generally only scoop out the poop. The silica crystals absorb urine, so you stir the litter between changes rather than scooping urine clumps. Some crystal litters are also formulated to help monitor changes in a cat’s urine.
- Pros: Easy to maintain, with generally low dust levels.
- Cons: Can be expensive, odor control varies, and they may not be ideal for multi-cat households.
Changing Litter Brand or Type

Sometimes we have no choice but to switch cat litter brands. A favorite litter might suddenly become unavailable, a manufacturer might discontinue it, or a store might stop carrying it.
I learned this firsthand during the 2023 Clorox cyberattack, when shortages made my favorite litter, Fresh Step Calm, difficult to find. And wouldn’t you know it, that litter has since been discontinued altogether!
That’s why it’s a good idea to have a couple of brands you know your cat will use, just in case your usual litter becomes unavailable. When I needed an alternative, I chose one with a similar texture, hoping my cats would accept the change.
If your cat starts avoiding the litter box after a change, don’t assume they’re being stubborn. The new litter may simply feel or smell wrong to them. If the problem continues, I can help you figure out what’s causing the litter box avoidance.
Help Choosing the Right Cat Litter
CAT LITTER COMPARISON CHART
Prices as of October 2026. Actual prices may vary by retailer, location, and promotions.
Still unsure which kitty litter is best for your cat? Below, I’ve listed the various cat litters I’ve personally tried. Whether you’re looking for a new litter or need to replace a favorite that’s no longer available, this chart can help you compare your options.
I’ve grouped the cat litters by type: Natural Substance, Clay, and Silica Crystals, and included the following factors:
- Price
- How well it clumps
- How well it controls odor
- Whether it’s low dust
- How comfortable it feels on those little kitty feet
I have an unusual number of cats! Just because a litter doesn’t meet the needs of my large cat household doesn’t mean it won’t be good for you and your cat, so review the chart carefully.
Remember, when choosing the right cat litter, the best cat litter for your cat is the one your cat will actually use! 😻
NATURAL SUBSTANCE CAT LITTERSHighly Recommended: World’s Best |
|||||
Brand |
Price |
Clumps Well |
Odor Control |
Low Dust |
Easy On Paws |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() |
$20.99–$23.39 for 15 lbs | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$24.98 for 18 lbs |
❌ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$14.50 for 20 lbs |
❌ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
![]() |
$22.00 for 25 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ❌ |
CLAY CAT LITTERSHighly Recommended: Fresh Step Calm, Cat’s Pride, Fresh Step Simply Unscented, Dr. Elsy’s |
|||||
Brand |
Price |
Clumps Well |
Odor Control |
Low Dust |
Easy On Paws |
![]() |
$14.29 for 15 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$15.50 for 11.5 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$18.24 for 20 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$14.49 for 20 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ✅ |
![]() |
$9.99 for 20 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
![]() |
$10.99 for 20 lbs |
✅ | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
![]() |
$10.49 14 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$14.99 20 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ❌ | ✅ |
SILICA CRYSTAL CAT LITTERSRecommended: Pretty Litter |
|||||
Brand |
Price |
Clumps Well |
Odor Control |
Low Dust |
Easy On Paws |
![]() |
24.73–$24.99 for 8 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$16.99 5 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ✅ |
![]() |
$23.99–$25.99 8 lbs |
❌ | ❌ | ✅ | ❌ |
Have a Cat Litter You’d Like Me to Try?
Is there a cat litter you love, or one you’re curious about that I haven’t reviewed yet? I’d love to hear about it! Send me a message through my contact form and tell me which litter you’d like me to put to the test.






















